& Insurance
When shopping for a vehicle, people typically focus on fuel efficiency, design, and performance. However, the choice of car significantly affects auto insurance premiums.
Insurance rates depend on multiple variables including driving history, location, and age—but the type of car you drive plays a major role in determining your insurance costs.
Certain vehicles are more expensive to repair, prone to theft, or statistically involved in more accidents, making them riskier to insure and resulting in higher premiums. Here are 10 types of cars that can raise your auto insurance.
GET A QUOTE
Enter Zip Code Below
Secure • Fast • No Obligation
1. Luxury Cars
Examples: BMW 7 Series, Mercedes-Benz S-Class, Audi A8
Premium features come with high repair costs requiring specialized parts and technicians. These vehicles are also attractive theft targets.
Why insurance is higher:
- Expensive parts and labor
- High theft rates
- Higher liability risk due to power and speed
2. Sports Cars
Examples: Chevrolet Corvette, Porsche 911, Dodge Challenger SRT Hellcat
Built for speed, these vehicles have higher accident rates. Drivers are perceived as risk-takers, and the capability to travel at high speeds increases the likelihood of severe collisions.
Why insurance is higher:
- Higher risk of speeding and accidents
- Expensive repairs
- Performance-based driving behavior
3. Electric Vehicles (EVs)
Examples: Tesla Model S, Rivian R1T, Lucid Air
Despite environmental benefits, EVs often carry higher premiums due to expensive battery technology repair or replacement and high-end cutting-edge features. Fewer specialized mechanics also increase labor costs.
Why insurance is higher:
- Costly battery replacements
- Advanced onboard technology
- Limited repair options
4. High-End SUVs
Examples: Range Rover, Cadillac Escalade, BMW X7
While offering extra safety features and space, these vehicles are expensive to replace, likely to cause significant damage in accidents due to their size and weight, and increase liability risks through damage inflicted on other vehicles.
Why insurance is higher:
- Expensive replacement value
- Greater potential for liability claims
- More likely to be stolen
5. Convertibles
Examples: Mazda MX-5 Miata, Ford Mustang Convertible, BMW Z4
Soft tops make these vehicles easier to break into and structurally less safe in accidents compared to hard-top cars. Convertibles often share risks with sports cars.
Why insurance is higher:
- Higher theft and vandalism risk
- Less structural safety in crashes
- Higher repair costs for unique parts
Tulsa Tip
Oklahoma's severe weather—including hail and storms—can be especially damaging to convertibles with soft tops, which may further increase your comprehensive coverage costs.
6. Cars Popular with Young Drivers
Examples: Honda Civic, Subaru WRX, Volkswagen GTI
Affordable and sporty vehicles appeal to younger drivers, who statistically experience more accidents. Insurers charge more for cars typically driven by inexperienced or high-risk groups.
Why insurance is higher:
- Associated with young or inexperienced drivers
- Higher accident rates
- Increased claim frequency
7. Modified or Tuned Cars
Examples: Any car with aftermarket turbochargers, lowered suspension, or performance exhaust systems
Modifications may improve performance or appearance but raise red flags for insurers. Customizations often invalidate factory safety standards, increase vehicle value, and suggest aggressive driving behavior.
Why insurance is higher:
- Increases performance and risk
- Difficult and costly to repair
- Limited coverage availability
8. Rare or Classic Cars
Examples: 1967 Ford Mustang, 1955 Chevrolet Bel Air, limited-edition models
Collector vehicles pose unique insurance challenges. They require specialty parts that may be discontinued or hard to find, and repairs and replacements can be extremely expensive.
Why insurance is higher:
- Hard-to-source parts
- High replacement value
- Specialized insurance policies needed
9. High-Theft Models
Examples: Honda Accord, Toyota Camry, Dodge Charger
Surprisingly, common vehicles are frequently stolen. Cars with easily resellable parts or minimal anti-theft technology are prime targets. Insurers monitor theft data closely, reflecting higher premiums for high-theft vehicles.
Why insurance is higher:
- Higher likelihood of theft
- Costly claim payouts
- Popular among car thieves for parts resale
Local Insight (Oklahoma Drivers)
Oklahoma consistently ranks among the states with higher vehicle theft rates. Installing anti-theft devices can help lower your comprehensive coverage premium—ask your insurer about available discounts.
10. New-to-Market Models
Examples: First-year releases of redesigned models or brand-new lines
Limited historical data on reliability, repair costs, and safety performance makes insurers cautious. Until sufficient data exists to evaluate risk accurately, they typically charge higher premiums.
Why insurance is higher:
- Lack of historical data
- Unknown repair costs
- No established risk profile
How to Manage High Insurance Costs
If you drive one of the vehicle types listed above, several strategies can help offset higher premiums:
- Shop around for insurance quotes before purchasing the vehicle
- Consider raising your deductible to lower monthly premiums
- Take advantage of bundled policies (home + auto)
- Ask about discounts for anti-theft devices, good driving records, or defensive driving courses
- Explore usage-based insurance programs for infrequent drivers
FAQs
Which types of cars have the highest insurance rates?
Luxury cars, sports cars, and high-end SUVs typically carry the highest insurance premiums due to expensive repairs, high theft rates, and increased liability risk.
Do electric vehicles cost more to insure?
Yes, EVs often carry higher premiums because of costly battery replacements, advanced onboard technology, and a limited number of specialized repair shops.
Can car modifications raise my insurance rate?
Absolutely. Aftermarket modifications like turbochargers, lowered suspension, or performance exhaust systems can increase your premium because they raise the vehicle's value and suggest higher-risk driving behavior.
Why do common cars like the Honda Accord have high insurance rates?
Common vehicles are frequently stolen because their parts are easily resellable. Insurers track theft data closely and adjust premiums accordingly.
How can I lower my insurance if I drive a high-risk vehicle?
Shop around for quotes, raise your deductible, bundle your policies, install anti-theft devices, and ask about discounts for good driving records or defensive driving courses.
Compare Your Rate Today
Find out how your vehicle type affects your premium. Enter your zip code below to get started.